Everton FC vs. Newcastle United

Newcastle United holds a narrow edge in trader consensus for this August 12 pre-season friendly at Murrayfield Stadium, reflecting the Magpies' deeper squad resources and recent Premier League positioning despite both clubs rotating heavily. Everton face notable absences including James Garner, who underwent groin surgery with a delayed return, Jarrad Branthwaite on hamstring recovery, and Dwight McNeil, limiting midfield and attacking options in preparations for the 2026/27 campaign. Newcastle contend with their own fitness concerns around Valentino Livramento, Fabian Schar, and Anthony Elanga, yet maintain stronger overall depth that supports the implied probability split. Historical head-to-head records remain competitive, while the non-competitive nature of the fixture emphasizes fitness testing over results, keeping the draw market viable amid typical pre-season unpredictability.