The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the US regulator of derivatives and event-contract markets, has told exchanges that a fast-growing class of prediction contracts is presumed manipulable and will face a higher bar to reach the market. In Staff Advisory No. 26-27, dated September 22, 2026, the agency's Division of Market Oversight (the CFTC unit that reviews and polices new product listings) said its staff "may view Mention Markets as presumptively readily susceptible to manipulation and accordingly expect a heightened showing in support of any submission seeking to list such contracts."

The advisory does not ban the contracts. It moves the burden onto platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket to prove, before a market opens, that a contract on whether a named person says a specific word or turns up at an event cannot be rigged. It landed two days after the CFTC closed two cases that show precisely how these markets get rigged: a White House teleprompter operator who traded on the speeches he was loading, and a former congressman who traded on whether he himself would show up to one.

Build your own theme park, free in your browserAd Advertise here

What a "mention market" is

A mention market is an event contract that settles on the conduct of a single named individual: whether a president uses a particular word in a speech, whether a public figure attends a ceremony, whether two people shake hands or pose for a photo. The appeal is obvious. These are the contracts that turn a State of the Union address or a state visit into a live, tradable event, and they are among the most-clicked markets these platforms run.

They are also, the CFTC now argues, structurally different from a market on an election result or an inflation print. An election has millions of independent voters; a mention market often turns on the choices of one person, and sometimes on the choices of people who can see the outcome coming before anyone else. That is the vulnerability the advisory is built around.

Board of Trade99%AnoNe
Melania95%AnoNe

The heightened showing, and why it bites

The advisory hangs on Designated Contract Market Core Principle 3, the long-standing rule that a listed contract must not be readily susceptible to manipulation. Most new event contracts reach the market through self-certification under the CFTC's Part 40 rules: an exchange files the contract, certifies that it meets the core principles, and can list it quickly unless the regulator objects. That streamlined path is what let prediction platforms roll out hundreds of markets at speed.

Staff Advisory 26-27 tightens that path for one category. By declaring mention markets "presumptively" manipulable, staff shift the starting position: instead of a contract being presumed compliant, the exchange must make an affirmative, heightened showing that this particular mention market is safe before it lists. A presumption is rebuttable, so the door is not closed, but the exchange now carries the weight, and a thin self-certification is far more likely to draw an objection.

The teleprompter operator who traded the script

The clearest illustration of the risk sits in a settlement the CFTC issued against Gabriel Perez, who worked as a White House teleprompter operator from roughly December 2025 to February 2026. In that job Perez saw the president's speeches before they were delivered, which meant he knew which words were coming. He traded presidential speech-word contracts on that advance knowledge.

The CFTC ordered Perez to pay $172,000: a disgorgement of $107,539.02, the profit the agency tied to the trades, plus a civil penalty of $65,000 that was discounted for his cooperation. He also accepted a three-year ban from trading. The case is the textbook version of what the advisory calls the "controlling individual" problem: when the person who decides the outcome, or who can see it first, is inside the market, the public order book is trading against information it cannot access.

The congressman who traded his own seat

The second case flips the same problem around. The CFTC ordered George Santos, the former US Representative from New York, to pay roughly $35,000 and accept a three-year ban and a cease-and-desist order for manipulative trading on a Kalshi contract asking who would attend the 2026 State of the Union address. Santos traded a market on his own attendance.

Between February 12 and February 25, 2026, he held Yes positions on his own appearance, then exited at a profit after his own public statements moved the price. The penalty broke down into a disgorgement of $17,569.98 and a civil penalty of $17,500. Where Perez had inside information, Santos had something arguably more direct: control. He was trading on a fact he alone could decide, and he could talk the price wherever he wanted before he sold.

Four questions an exchange now has to answer

The advisory does not leave "heightened showing" undefined. Staff set out the factors an exchange has to address to rebut the presumption, and together they read as a checklist drawn straight from the two cases. First, the obligations of the controlling individual: does anyone with power over the outcome have a duty that limits their trading? Second, vulnerability to outside pressure: can the individual be leaned on, paid, or talked into a result? Third, verifiability: is the outcome transparent and open to public scrutiny, or does it come down to one disputable judgment call? Fourth, the exchange's own trading rules and surveillance: can the platform actually detect a Perez or a Santos in its order flow?

An exchange that wants to list a market on a handshake or a spoken word now has to answer all four in its filing, not after a regulator or a journalist catches the trade.

What changes for the platforms and the people trading

For Kalshi and Polymarket the practical effect is friction where there used to be none. The individual-conduct contracts are cheap to invent and popular to trade, and the old self-certification path let them appear almost on demand. The new posture means each one arrives with a compliance cost and a real chance of an objection, which is likely to thin out the most novel markets: the photo, the handshake, the single-word call.

For traders, the advisory is less a restriction than a signal about which markets were never a fair fight. In a mention market, the edge frequently belongs to whoever is closest to the microphone or the door, and the public ledger only exposes that after the position is closed. Perez and Santos were caught because the trades sit on a record; the advisory is the CFTC trying to stop the next one before the contract even opens.

Part of a wider tightening

The mention-markets guidance is one piece of a broader 2026 effort by the CFTC to bring prediction markets under firmer oversight, alongside separate staff advisories this year on self-certification and on incentive programs. Read together, they mark a shift in how Washington treats a product that spent the last two years growing faster than its rulebook.

It took a $172,000 settlement against a teleprompter operator and a roughly $35,000 one against George Santos for the CFTC to write this rule down, and Staff Advisory 26-27 is the agency deciding it will no longer learn about the next Perez or Santos from the settlement paperwork. Before the following contract on a spoken word or a handshake goes live, an exchange has to satisfy all four Core Principle 3 factors and prove the named person at the center of it cannot quietly trade the outcome, which is the exact move Gabriel Perez made from inside the White House and Santos made from his own seat in the House chamber. That proof is now the price of listing the kind of market these platforms built their traffic on.